•   500 Legacy Farms North, Hopkinton MA 01748
Baypath Humane Society of Hopkinton
  • Search
  • Icon menu
    • ADOPT
      • About Adoption
      • Available Cats
      • Available Dogs
      • Success Stories
    • SUPPORT US
      • Donate Now
      • Gifts of Stock
      • Corporate Giving
      • Lilly & Orchid Fund
      • Sponsor a Pen
      • Planned Giving
      • Your Impact
      • Our Wish List
      • Shop our Merchandise
    • GET INVOLVED
      • Volunteer
      • Become a Foster Family
        • Foster a Cat or Kittens
        • Foster a Dog or Puppy
        • Explore Foster Life
      • Youth Opportunities
    • ABOUT US
      • Our Team
      • Our Board of Directors
      • Our History
      • Our Work
        • Animal Care Professionals
        • Commitment to Enrichment
        • Pet Pantry Programs
        • Pilot Surgical Program
      • Our Vision
      • Supporting Partners
      • Contact us
      • Annual Report
    • SERVICES
      • Animal Transport Program
      • Barn Cat Program
      • Baypath Educates
      • Humane Lecture Series
      • Last Litter Program
      • Outreach Program
      • Rehoming Your Pet
      • Shadow Cat Program
    • NEWS & EVENTS
      • Event Calendar
      • Signature Events
        • Fore Paws Golf Tournament
        • Fur Ball
        • Paws & Claws 5k
      • Special Offers
    • RESOURCES
      • Animal Care Professionals
      • Animal Cruelty Laws
      • Assistance Programs
      • Baypath FAQ’s
      • Caring for Your Cat
      • Caring for Your Dog
      • Dog Training & Behavior
      • Lost & Found Resources
    • Donate
  •   500 Legacy Farms North, Hopkinton MA 01748
Baypath Humane Society of Hopkinton
  • ADOPT
    • About Adoption
    • Available Cats
    • Available Dogs
    • Available Small Animals
    • Success Stories
  • SUPPORT US
    • Donate Now
    • Gifts of Stock
    • Corporate Giving
    • Lilly & Orchid Fund
    • Sponsor a Pen
    • Planned Giving
    • Your Impact
    • Our Wish List
    • Purchase for Paws
  • GET INVOLVED
    • Volunteer
    • Become a Foster Family
      • Foster a Cat or Kittens
      • Foster a Dog or Puppy
    • Youth Opportunities
  • ABOUT US
    • Our Team
    • Our Board of Directors
    • Our History
    • Our Work
      • Animal Control Partnerships
      • Commitment to Enrichment
      • Pet Pantry Programs
      • Pilot Surgical Program
    • Our Vision
    • Supporting Partners
    • Contact us
    • Annual Report
  • SERVICES
    • Animal Transport Program
    • Barn Cat Program
    • Baypath Educates
    • Humane Lecture Series
    • Last Litter Program
    • Outreach Program
    • Rehoming Your Pet
    • Shadow Cat Program
  • NEWS & EVENTS
    • Event Calendar
    • Signature Events
      • Fore Paws Golf Tournament
      • Fur Ball
      • Paws & Claws 5k
    • Special Offers
  • RESOURCES
    • Animal Care Professionals
    • Animal Cruelty Laws
    • Assistance Programs
    • Caring for Your Cat
    • Caring for Your Dog
    • Dog Training & Behavior
    • Baypath FAQ’s
    • Lost & Found Resources
  • Donate

A Tail of Two Kitties

Homepage Cat Behavior A Tail of Two Kitties
Cat Behavior, Cat Care, News, Resources, Success Stories

A Tail of Two Kitties

August 15, 2024
By Baypath Staff member
0 Comment
3546 Views

On a cold January day, Baypath welcomed eighteen local cats seeking a fresh start from challenging living conditions. Our staff, using inspiration from the Disney movie Frozen, named two of the new arrivals Princess Anna and Princess Elsa. Like most cats who begin their lives without proper socialization, Anna and Elsa were both shy and nervous around people. However, they demonstrated increased confidence and relaxation in each other’s company, as they could lean on one another for courage and support.

 

It did not take long before these two pretty kitties caught the eye of Baypath Board Member Amy Schrepfer-Tarter, PhD. Inspired to become involved in animal sheltering as a way to honor the memory of a previous beloved feline companion, Amy has played a key role in Baypath’s signature events including our Fur Ball since she joined the board in 2019.

Instantly smitten with the movie star princesses, Amy decided to give the adorable duo a fresh start. Just as the iconic Frozen song sings of ‘letting go of your past,’ the two cats quickly settled in their new home, a happy and bonded family. To cement their fresh start, Amy bestowed the name ‘Tullia’ to Anna, while Elsa became known as ‘Olivia.’

Two months later, an unexpected altercation between the sisters resulted in Tullia displaying aggression towards Olivia. The tension became so intense that Tullia was distressed even by Olivia’s scent. When multiple attempts to separate, offer decompression and reintroduce were unsuccessful, Amy feared her once happy little family could not be salvaged. 

Understanding the importance of securing assistance for serious behavioral concerns, Amy sought help from Dr. Rachel Geller, a certified Humane Education, Cat Behavior and Retention Specialist and Founder & President of ‘All Cats All the Time, Inc.,’ a nonprofit organization dedicated to promoting cat adoption while preventing owner surrender and abandonment. Dr. Geller’s free behavioral counseling and collaboration with shelters and cat owners worldwide ensures cats and their owners lead harmonious lives. Baypath frequently recommends Dr. Geller’s services to overwhelmed cat owners, thus helping to prevent surrenders and allowing cats to stay in their homes with families who love them.

The detailed behavioral reintroduction plan created by Dr. Geller required dedication and patience from Amy. Steps included parallel play sessions, feeding schedules, baby gates and separating Tullia into a different bedroom. Amy found it challenging but necessary to adjust her own responses, which made the process a learning experience for both cats and human alike!

Amy explains that despite setbacks and bumps along the way, Rachel’s support, empathy and communication were invaluable. “I can’t put into words how her guidance saved our family,” she says. After diligently following the reintroduction plan for two months and receiving continuous support from Dr. Geller, Tullia and Olivia’s journey concluded successfully! The girls have restored their inseparable bond and enjoy life with Amy as snuggly, inseparable sisters.

Dr. Geller explains it is not uncommon for sudden tension to develop between feline pairs, as it did with Tullia and Olivia. Even a simple trip to the vet with one cat, bringing the scents of the veterinary office home, can lead to one cat treating the other differently. Whether reintroducing  previously bonded pairs or introducing a brand new cat to the household, Dr. Geller offers this comprehensive step-by-step video, accessible on Baypath’s Caring for Your Cat Resource page.

Can’t get enough of Dr. Geller’s incredible insights?

Read on for Development Coordinator Katy Kesselman’s informative interview with this feline superstar!

 

Katy: Our team knows all too well how crucial careful introductions are to successful transitions. Can you please tell us about Amy Schrepfer-Tarter’s recent bonded pair reintroduction process?  

Rachel: Amy had adopted two cats from Baypath. For some unknown reason, their once blissful relationship had devolved into a destructive cycle of fear and aggression. Once this happens, the best course of action is to go through a complete reintroduction process, going through every step as if the cats have never met each other before.

A proper reintroduction is necessary to lay the foundation for how your cats will see each other and the associations they have with each other in the future. If the cats start out calmly, safely and securely with this reintroduction process, this will carry them into a tolerant relationship. Cats are territorial, so it is important to understand their need to feel secure in their own territory. The right reintroduction will accomplish this and with a proper reintroduction and going at the cat’s pace, fears can be kept to a minimum.

The reintroduction must be gradual and positive to meet the needs of both of your cats. 

Amy stayed in touch with me every step of the way as I guided her through the process. I told Amy I preferred she reach out if she had any questions or concerns or just wanted to be reassured, rather than guessing or feeling unsure.

Katy: What should every adopter know about introducing a new kitten or cat into their home?

Rachel: You always want to start your new cat off in her own room, preferably a small one, because too much new territory too soon will be overwhelming.

Once you’ve selected your sanctuary room, you’ll want to make sure the space is cat-proofed and ready for your new arrival. Make sure there are no hiding places in the room. If there is a bed, bureau or other furniture in the room that a cat could hide under, put luggage, boxes or storage containers underneath. You don’t want your new cat to spend her days hiding from you. Your cat will want to hide as a way to cope with all of the changes in her life, so we want to block off under the bed and bureau but give her places to hide that are accessible to you, such as a cat tunnel, covered cat bed or even a box on its side.

Make sure there are no little cracks or holes in the walls. Cats have moveable collar bones, so if a cat can get her head into a space, she can get her entire body in there.

Make sure there is food and water on one side, and a scratching post and litter box on the other side. Cats love the warmth of the sun and/or a radiator, so place a cat bed in an area where there is a “sun puddle” or a few feet away from a radiator. Place the toys on the floor away from the walls so the cat can easily engage with and move the toy.

When you think your cat is ready to see the rest of the home, do it in incremental stages. Don’t force your new cat to try to establish her territory in your entire house all at once. This will be way too scary and overwhelming for her. Before you open the door to the sanctuary room, close the doors to some of your other rooms. You can shut bedroom doors, and if you have more than one floor, you can use a tall baby gate or garden lattice so that you can have your new cat start with one level of the home first.

Katy: Can you share some tips on how to ensure the most seamless feline transitions possible from shelter to home? 

Rachel: On that special day that you bring home your new cat, go directly to the room you have set up as the sanctuary room. Close the door gently behind you and place the carrier on the floor. Open the carrier door, but don’t force the cat out. Don’t reach in and pull her out. Let the cat come out at her own pace. You can take the door off the carrier, or tie the door back with a pipe cleaner or baggie tie. This way, your new cat still has the safety and security of her carrier for as long as she needs it. At the beginning, this is the only place that has her familiar scents.

Spray a synthetic pheromone product in the sanctuary room and also on the door frames. Cats deposit their own pheromones on objects as a signal that this is a friendly, feel-good place. Synthetic pheromones will trick the cat into thinking she has already designated her sanctuary room as her own territory.

Anytime she is in her safe spot, a good thing to do would be to just sit next to her on the floor and read, do work, or talk on the phone. Find that spot where your new cat will accept you, and be near her as often as possible. Sit on the floor and do your own thing – call some friends, relatives, update your Facebook, work on your laptop – you get the idea. A good rule is to have something in your hands, and be looking at that item in your hands. Don’t make any overtures toward her so that – from her point of view – you come off as non-threatening. She will eventually feel that it is safe to come closer and investigate you. It helps to get down to the cat’s level when interacting with her instead of towering over her, so try to sit on the floor as much as possible. If you can’t sit on the floor, maybe use a pillow or a low chair.

Be sure to hang out with her as much as possible, but don’t reach for her or make the first move. Follow her lead. Let the cat set the pace of the interaction. In these matters, it is always best to go at the cat’s pace. Be calm, encouraging and supportive with your voice. The cat will understand.

Lavish love and attention on your cat with your voice. Tell her how much you love her. Keep earning her trust with daily care, playtime and routine.

You want to keep your cat in the sanctuary room until she seems comfortable and unafraid. Depending on your cat, this could be several days to a couple of weeks. Let your cat set the pace. If she is hiding, then she is not ready to come out to the rest of the house yet. If she is greeting you at the door when you come in, following you when you leave or even trying to get out of the room, those are signs that she is getting ready to explore the territory on the other side of the door. Let your new cat learn to feel confident in her new territory first, and this will also help her to bond with you.

Katy: What makes behaviorists like yourself so vitally important to both adopters and shelter staff?

Rachel: Many cat owners do not realize that most cat behavior problems are fixable, and this leads to people surrendering their cats to already overcrowded shelters. They decide to surrender their cat due to barriers such as finances and access to cat behavior help. In these cases, the cat is already in a loving home, so my goal as a cat behaviorist is surrender prevention. I want to make sure that the cat remains in her home by working with the owner to resolve the behavior issue. 

Cat behavior help is an important resource to adopters and shelter staff. When cat behavior intervention leads to surrender prevention, we save two lives – the cat who was going to be surrendered stays in her home, and this frees up a spot in the shelter for a cat who is truly homeless. Surrender prevention reduces shelter intakes that are due to behavior so we can focus on the cats who truly need shelter and rescue, thus saving more cats. A side benefit is that this program builds positive connections between shelters, rescues and people within our communities. 

 Katy: Do you have any advice for someone considering reaching out for behavioral support for their furry family member?

Rachel: Go for it! I provide my services completely free of charge and it is always best to err on the side of caution. Most cat behavior problems can be fixed!

 


Previous Story
Snow White’s Magical Transformation
Next Story
Roadie, the Remarkable Pitbull

Related Articles

322 Days in Limbo: The Story We Couldn’t Share—Until Now

From Rescue to Renewal: Dogs Seized from Wrentham Breeding Operation...

An image of a grey and white dog on the left side and a black Bermese cat on the right side.

Close to Home: Baypath's Impact on Local Animals - Part 34

Mercy, Nala, and Simba each got a second chance—trading heartbreak...

Recent Post

  • 322 Days in Limbo: The Story We Couldn’t Share—Until Now May 20, 2025
  • Close to Home: Baypath’s Impact on Local Animals – Part 34 May 18, 2025
  • Close to Home: Baypath’s Impact on Local Animals – Part 33 May 11, 2025
  • Adapting to change, committed to care. May 08, 2025
  • A Mother’s Day Story: Six New Beginnings May 07, 2025

Tags

Baypathhumane Cat care tips Charity Dog Dog Training Education End of year Enviroment Fall Appeal Fearful Dogs Fore Paws Foster foster-success-stories From the desk of Giving Tuesday Golf Grant Lecture Series 2019 Litter box issues New Shelter Pet Safety Puppy separation anxiety Spay & Neuter Success stories Succes Stories Support Us Volunteer Volunteer of the year
Baypath Humane Society
Baypath Humane Society of Hopkinton is dedicated to providing shelter, care, humane treatment and loving homes for stray or unwanted companion animals.

News

  • 322 Days in Limbo: The Story We Couldn’t Share—Until Now May 20, 2025
  • Close to Home: Baypath’s Impact on Local Animals – Part 34 May 18, 2025
  • Close to Home: Baypath’s Impact on Local Animals – Part 33 May 11, 2025

Quick Links

  • Adopt
  • Donate
  • Get involved
  • Contact Us
  • Resources

ALUMNI

Medium sized brown and black dog smiling up at the camera
Walter and Nicholas playing in the snow
Header image of two small white dogs, Cooper and Lightfoot, in sweaters kissing.
Image of Dexter's, a white, black, and brown pitbull laying on his back with legs sticking up in the air.
Copyright ©2025 Baypath Humane Society. All Rights Reserved.
MDAR License #213
Privacy Policy & Terms of Use
SearchPostsLogin
Tuesday, 20, May
322 Days in Limbo: The Story We Couldn’t Share—Until Now
Sunday, 18, May
Close to Home: Baypath’s Impact on Local Animals – Part 34
Sunday, 11, May
Close to Home: Baypath’s Impact on Local Animals – Part 33
Thursday, 8, May
Adapting to change, committed to care.
Wednesday, 7, May
A Mother’s Day Story: Six New Beginnings
Tuesday, 6, May
Close to Home: Baypath’s Impact on Local Animals – Part 32

Welcome back,